The Lost Dutchman’s Mine Gold Mine of Authors

It’s the stuff that makes for a great story and grabs people’s attention who enjoy one: The Lost Dutchman’s Gold Mine. The stories about the fabled mine in Arizona’s Superstition Mountains has fascinated any number of people and inspired as many as 8,000 people a year to go looking for it. Everyone thinks they will be the one to find it. Some people have died looking for it, even in recent years. The mystery and danger keep people fascinated as well as the promise of riches and fame.

The story has dubious beginnings, none of which seem to play out to anything substantive. It’s named after a German (“Dutchman”) named Jacob Waltz who supposedly worked the mine and was found dead in the mountains or thereabout. Since then, rumor has led many people to look for it, some of whom wound up dead in mysterious circumstance – seemingly. There are older stories that include a mine originally run by the Peralta family as well as Native American legends and curses. To date, no one has found any such site, if it ever existed.

Whether there is actually such an old mine in existence is debatable but it makes a great tale to base around a good book if you are so inclined. But today, I’m not so much interested in the mine or writing about it (though it makes for a great starter). Instead, I’d like to address the author’s version of the mine – marketing.

There seem to be a lot of people out there hawking lessons and books about how to become a bestseller and I don’t purport to have any special knowledge about these or marketing. However, let me pass along some useful tidbits I’ve learned over the last few years.

Nothing is as it seems, or how it’s presented by other people. Some people do well in general while others do not. But I learned very quickly that you must lower your own expectations. No, lower than that. I mean to rock-bottom, maybe up a box-canyon. It’s not as easy as some make it out or they wouldn’t be selling a how-to for so much money.

Will all those courses work? Maybe, maybe not. There are lots of factors involved in marketing and they change constantly. There are some basics like a good blurb, good book, newsletter, blog/website and several others that should be mastered over time. You won’t build your author brand in a day but work at it daily.

Photo courtesy stockarch via Morguefile.

When I published my first book, I expected it would not gain much attention at all. I knew this fact going into the release of the book. But the sound of crickets afterward was still deafening and disappointing. I knew it wouldn’t do well since I had no audience but the long line of no sales on the reports was soul-crushing.

Months went by and I determined I would do something to work on those sales, mostly because I had more time after some professional and personal projects ended. I set a goal of getting to 3-5 sales a day. That was May of 2016 and the month ended with about 1.5 sales a day; not what I targeted but better than my previous nine months.

After Labor Day of 2016, sales took off into the thousands for several months and it was ranked highly on Amazon. I’ve been there with a book, my first book no less. But how did that happen? Well, that’s a mystery to me but here are a few thoughts. First, when I lowered my book price to 99 cents for an extended time, sales took off during the prime selling season from Labor Day through the end of the year (acutally into February of 2017). Next, I had also spent several months working on getting reviews of the book but sales helped that more than anything. Last, marketing was a key element that included being on a number of paid newsletter services and other marketing over social media. Most of all, traffic to your book sales page is important, followed by conversion rate (see the Amazon ads book link below for more information).

Sales slipped over 2017 until the release of my next book in April of that year after which I raised the price of my first book back to $2.99. It was still a good year for sales as I released my third book in October of last year. More books made it easier to market but sales were not what I wanted and, looking back, I probably should have reduced The Bow of Destiny back to 99 cents during September-December but that’s hard to do when you’re out of work.

But marketing had changed during the year so some of what I had done previously proved less effective. Also, I had less money to sink into marketing since I was out of work most of the year. But there are some takeaways that I’ve gained by continually researching what can sell books.

  • Newsletters: your own, other authors and paid services can be a big help because your book lands right in front of people.
  • Social Media: not near as much of a return as newsletters though some help from other people is great and some services can help.
  • Ads: this is a slippery slope since you can spend  waste a lot of money with little return if you are not careful. But done well, ads can help if you achieve the correct ROI.

What is my current approach? I continue to seek out the wisdom of others and I have a few resources listed at the end of this post. I keep a steady stream of low-cost ads running each week. My Facebook ads are on a low spend and geared toward getting traffic to my books. They seem to garner a good number of clicks so I keep them running at a low cost. I dabble with Amazon ads, again working to get traffic to my book pages. I work to grow my newsletter subscribers, but mainly this is an investment for future releases.

One of the main decisions I made late last year was to shift away from listing my books anywhere other than Amazon. The reason is clear based on my accounting of sales. Other sites combined did not add up to 20% of my total sales. I shifted to Kindle Select and put the books into Kindle Unlimited. This keeps a pretty good income stream flowing each month. It’s been enough to plan my marketing budget better and save for the production of more books.

Some people might say that they make lots of money from books and they just might. In my experience, more books published means more sales. Writing a series seems to bring in more sales (and KU downloads). But the ultimate answer is that you need to have steady traffic to your book sales pages to achieve regular sales. That means you need dedicate some time and money to marketing. Regarding the latter, some sort of part-time side-income or savings can help seed your efforts.

What would I have done differently with my initial book? I would have had a better marketing plan from the start. Lesson learned. I would have lowered my price much sooner since it was the only way to gain sales for a first novel by an unknown author – this grew my audience. Who is your audience? The readers of your highest selling book in each genre in which you publish books. The drawback of 99 cents is a much lower return on your marketing investment and it only gets better with subsequent books.

Continuing with lessons learned, I would have put more time into a newsletter sooner but that is an ongoing effort. Also, I obsessed over marketing during much of 2016 to the detriment of writing another book. If I had published book two sooner, things would have also improved sooner for overall sales income. I would also have more books published by now.

Instead of expecting large numbers of sales all at once, I now look for long-term sales while I add more books to my list. But it is important to dedicate yourself – time and money – to marketing. How much should you spend? As much as you are able while bringing in a viable return. But, you must take personal responsibility for failure as well as success, while understanding that things keep changing. One thing I can say is that you should be careful to target readers in your genre in your every approach because this makes a difference with sales on Amazon.

I cannot direct anyone to the lost mine and I think that those who do should be taken with a grain of salt since some may well be working off affiliate marketing of courses to make a living. Does the information presented by such courses help? Probably, but in varying degrees.

Here are some resources I’ve used that help me with the least expense:

  1. Mastering Amazon Ads: An Author’s Guide
  2. Six Figure Author: Using Data to Sell Books
  3. Udemy Courses (note: some claim high sales but check the rankings of the books they actually sell and Udemy has sales days when you can purchase these for as low as $10).

I’m not a marketing guru but I try to approach things as practically as I can while I work diligently at it every day. I can say that a business should become profitable (make some money) after five years. I’m in my third year and things are slowly changing for the better but I have a long way to go and more books to publish. What are your marketing experiences? What ads or services work for you? Do you budget for marketing? Do you market for everyday or just special days and releases? Thanks for reading today.

P.H. Solomon

23 thoughts on “The Lost Dutchman’s Mine Gold Mine of Authors

  1. Pingback: The Week in Review | Joan Hall (Blog)

  2. Pingback: Author Inspiration and This Week’s Writing Links | Staci Troilo

  3. Thank you for this article. It is good to know that others also struggle with marketing and getting a brand built. I have also been working on a 5 to 7 year plan. That is how long it took me to get my full qualification as a chartered accountant and I feel writing should be the same. You have to build it slowly. I have 6 books available all for children and the sales are just starting to pick up a bit which is rewarding.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Excellent! There are tons of these “become rich quick” writing courses around the Internet. Someone is getting rich. The creators of the courses. But as you say, there are specific things we need but I don’t think one size fits all. Thanks for the informative post today, P. H.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Thank you for a very informative post. I tried going outside of KDP Select on my first book and it failed miserably. I’ve stayed with KDP since. Like the others that have commented, I too have tried FB ads, paid newsletters, and paid book review sites. They all failed. I have never tried Amazon Product Display Ads. Do I assume when you discuss Amazon AMS ads we are speaking of the same thing? I have been fairly successful with Sponsored Product Ads. Using Sponsored ads is a slow process, but does work if you keep up with it. It is a difficult process to keep up with Amazon’s algorithms system and I don’t believe there is a winning solution. If you can ever get on the first page of best sellers, then you have a chance. Bottom line, it is not easy to self-publish. If it was, we all would be millionaires.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks Chuck. It does take hard work to move things along. Market awareness also helps. I do the sponsored ads . I’ve never even gotten an ad to run that appears on Kindles. Maybe I should revisit that when I have time.

      Liked by 1 person

  6. Fantastic post, P.H.! Thanks for those links at the bottom too. I’ve tried a number of different marketing strategies over the years. Right now I tend to stick with a combination of social media connections, newsletters (my own and paid) and FB ads. I generally only pay for advertising when I have a new release or a reduced price book. I agree that to maintain a steady stream of income, you need a steady stream of releases. I went a full year without a release between the end of my last series and the start of my new one, and the first two quarters of this year definitely reflected that. I keep toying with the idea of doing Amazon Ads but haven’t taken the time to learn the ropes yet. As much as I dislike Facebook, I do normally see results on ads I run. I just wish there were a way to run ads without needing to have a social presence there. Until I can figure out something to take it’s place, I think I’m going to be married to FB.

    Liked by 1 person

    • AMS ads take some maintenance. I’d read the book and then do most of it weekly or monthly but watch the spend closely depending on budget. You can also use ads on BookBub – those are now available based on clicks for payment as are the ones for Goodreads. Both of those I set to run for a while and just want to get impressions at least for them. With Goodreads getting people to shelve your books can lead to sales later and the reports to show how much your books are getting shelved.

      Liked by 1 person

    • The Six Figure Author explains a lot about approaches to Amazon’s marketing algorithms and how to market for that. I’m working through the assignments in that book slowly but it’s a helpful concept. Neither book is very long. With FB, I mention that my books are in KU and use a hashtag and send people straight to the pages. I budget low per week and see low cost per click over months. The important part is using targeting well enough. I can target some other countries where the readers love the covers and probably purchase in other Amazon locations. The key is getting clicks to the book pages for conversions.

      Liked by 1 person

  7. I’m not a good marketer. I have creative ideas, but lack funds. I too have been burned by advertising that delivers nothing. Right now, I’m stuffing books in bottles and figuratively dropping them in the Amazon ocean.

    Liked by 2 people

  8. This is a great post on marketing, PH! This whole area is something I continue to try to get to grips with. I am currently using Amazon Ads to boost sales, but that is something I have to learn more about, especially those keywords, and I have no clue about Amazon algorithms. I’ve wasted so much money on companies that just don’t deliver, so I’m quite wary nowadays. I’ve had the book ‘Mastering Amazon Ads’ on my e-reader for a while, but I haven’t been disciplined enough to make myself sit and go through it, lols. I need to crack that whip! Best of luck with everything, and thanks for sharing your journey 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

We'd love to know what you think. Comment below.

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s