Basic Plots: Comedy

Comedy Tragedy MasksCiao, SEers. On March 21, I started a series of posts on the seven basic plot types, as defined by Christopher Booker. So far, we’ve covered Rebirth and Tragedy. Today, we’re going to talk about Comedy.

Comedies aren’t necessarily laugh-out-loud humor pieces, although they can be. Essentially, these are works with happy or uplifting endings. The tone throughout will typically be lighter than that of a tragedy, but it can still be a dramatic story.

A comedy is about triumph over adversity. A series of problems—often mistakes or secrets—stymie the hero. Characters are out of harmony because of frustration, selfishness, bitterness, confusion, lies, etc. Finally, clarity is achieved and the ending is a positive one. Many times this resolution is depicted through a marriage of the hero and heroine. Because of this, it should come as no surprise that most romances and fairy tales fall into this category.

Here’s a list of some of the better-known comedies:

  • Much Ado About Nothing
  • The Merchant of Venice
  • Singin’ in the Rain
  • Guys and Dolls
  • Ocean’s Eleven

Here’s a basic template for writing a comedy. I’ll use Guys and Dolls as my example.

  1. Establish the Status Quo.
    This really isn’t a surprise. Most works establish the storyworld before introducing the inciting incident.
    In the case of Guys and Dolls, Sky Masterson is a gambler—not just a high roller, but the highest of rollers. A bit of a legend. He’s been known to bet ridiculous amounts of money on the most trivial things. He’s in town during Nathan Detroit’s big floating craps game, but he’s not really interested in it. Isn’t interested in a side bet Nathan tries to goad him into, either. On the other hand, we have Sister Sarah, who runs a mission. She’s a pure as they come. But her mission is failing, and she needs sinners to work with or the mission will be closed.
  2. Confusion and Isolation
    The purpose here is to stack everyone against each other. Sow the seeds of misunderstandings and keep everybody apart.
    In Guys and Dolls, Nathan needs money, and Sky won’t take his side bet, but he’s interested when Nathan wagers he can’t take Sarah to Havana. This is new, and so he accepts the challenge. And he wins. He gets her to Havana, where she gets drunk and admits her love for him. Meanwhile, Nathan uses her absence to host his floating craps game at the mission. When Sky and Sarah return and she learns what happened, she blames Sky, who was actually oblivious. Now she’s angry with him for using her and humiliating her, and he’s confused because he’d been winning her over, and now—through no fault of his own—he’s lost her.
  3. Raise the Stakes
    This is where more confusions are added to the mix, and the puzzle looks impossible to solve.
    In Guys and Dolls, Nathan tries to pay Sky, but Sky lies (to protect Sarah’s reputation) and claims he lost, so he pays Nathan instead. Nathan’s game can then continue, and Sky goes to it even though he declined the invitation before. Instead of betting the guys for money, he puts his money up against their “souls” so he can help Sarah. If he loses, he’ll pay out a fortune. But if he wins, they have to go to the mission so it doesn’t close—not a typical wager for any of these men.
  4. Problems Solved
    All of the miscommunications finally come to light, and the confusion is cleared up. The characters get their happily-ever-after ending.
    In Guys and Dolls, Sarah learns that Sky was not involved in the craps game at the mission and that he really does love her. So much so that he helped save her mission, and without asking anything of her in return. After the confusion is cleared up, they realize they’re in love, then the gambler and the mission “doll” end up getting married.

Contemporary comedies are often resolved with a happy ending for a romantic couple—a wedding, or at least the decision to be together. Romances aren’t the only comedies, though. Any situation with a “comedy of errors” (see what I did there?) that ends in an uplifting way qualifies.

Have you written a comedy? Do you have a favorite you’ve watched or read? Share in the comments.

Staci Troilo

59 thoughts on “Basic Plots: Comedy

  1. Pingback: Basic Plots: Overcoming the Monster | Story Empire

  2. Pingback: Basic Plots: Comedy — Story Empire | Clairsentient1

  3. I have to once again apologize for being off the radar. I was on vacation, something I hate to announce before I go because I’m uncomfortable with proclaiming travel plans and an empty house. Funny thing is, the house wasn’t even empty, as we had dog sitters. Still, old habits die hard.

    In any case, I owe a huge thanks to my colleagues, who stepped up to cover for me. I really do work with a phenomenal group of authors/friends, and I hope they know how much I appreciate them.


  4. I have never tried to write comedy, but I do LOVE watching a good comedy that makes me laugh out loud. I loved all of the National Lampoon movies and Planes, Trains and Automobiles is another at the top of my list. I always enjoy any comedy Goldie Hawn stars in. It’s good for the soul to laugh out loud! Thanks for sharing, Staci.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. I love a good comedy, Jennifer Crusie novels come to mind. One of my favorites is Agnes and The Hitman, written with Bob Mayer. Here’s part of the blurb from Amazon: Take one food writer named Cranky Agnes, add a hitman named Shane, mix them together with a Southern mob wedding, a missing necklace, two annoyed flamingos, and a dog named Rhett and you’ve got a recipe for a sexy, hilarious novel about the disastrous side of true love…
    She’s so good at creating friction between her characters, yet keeping them relatable. It’s not easy to write a series of comedic errors and yet give depth and empathy so readers connect.

    Liked by 3 people

  6. I love “comedy of errors” type books and have written a few of them in my day. All short stories, one with a romantic theme, the others, just fun. I have every intention of someday working them into a book of shorts—if I ever find the time to devote to that project.

    Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night and A Midsummer’s Night Dream are two favorites of mine. And I just finished reading a wonderful book that follows the comedy of errors theme, called The Fleecing of Fort Griffin. I’ll be sharing more about it on SE for my upcoming book share. Truly, laugh-out-loud funny!

    Liked by 3 people

Leave a Reply to John W. Howell Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s